I liked Now & Then, but I didn’t love it.
Usually when this happens, I can list what I did and didn’t like about the book. I’m finding that difficult to do. The book was pleasant enough. There wasn’t really anything I disliked about it. There wasn’t a lot that I strongly liked, either.
From the book cover:
Anna O’Shea has failed at marriage, shed her job at a law firm, and she’s trying to re-create herself when she and her recalcitrant nephew are summoned to the past in a manner that nearly destroys them. Her twenty-first-century skills pale as she struggles to find her nephew in nineteenth-century Ireland. For one of them, the past is brutally difficult, filled with hunger and struggle. For the other, the past is filled with privilege, status, and a reprieve from the crushing pain of present-day life. For both Anna and her nephew, the past offers them a chance at love.
Will every choice they make reverberate down through time? And do Irish Wolfhounds carry the soul of the ancient celts?
The past and present wrap around finely wrought characters who reveal the road home. Mystical, charming, and fantastic, New York Times bestselling author Jacqueline Sheehan’s Now & Then is a poignant and beautiful tale of a remarkable journey. It is a miraculous evocation of a breathtaking place in a volatile age filled with rich, unforgettable, deeply human characters and one unforgettable dog named Madigan.
I think the plot had a lot of promise, and I’m not quite sure why it didn’t feel like it delivered. It got tangled in time travel paradoxes, of course, but that’s what’s supposed to happen. I’d be disappointed in a time travel book that didn’t!
Anna had her moments, and I’m not sure why I didn’t her more than I did. She had an interesting background. I think I got tired of being told what a strong person she was. I rarely felt it. She didn’t seem weak. I just didn’t have a good rapport with her as a character.
Joseph was an appropriately obnoxious teenager. I didn’t like him much, but I wasn’t supposed to. I was sympathetic to his situation, both his back-story before the book began, and the events of the book itself.
I did appreciate the look at Irish history, and the dynamics of the relationship between the English and the Irish. It’s something I don’t know very much about, and now I’d like to know more.
I wish Madigan (the dog) had more of a role. I wish there had been a bit more grey and a bit less black and white. I wish it’d just had a little more of whatever it was that was missing.
It wasn’t a bad read, but it could have been better. I apologize for the wishy-washy review!
I read this book for a TLC Book Tour. Thank you to Trish for giving me the opportunity to participate.
To see some other opinions, see the other tour stops:
- Monday, November 2nd: The Bluestocking Guide
- Wednesday, November 4th: Yule Time Reading
- Thursday, November 5th: Life in the Thumb
- Thursday, November 12th: I’m Booking It
- Tuesday, November 17th: The Brain Lair
- Wednesday, November 18th: Bloggin’ ’bout Books
- Monday, November 23rd: Stephanie’s Written Word
- Monday, November 30th: Jenn’s Bookshelves
- Tuesday, December 1st: The Tome Traveller